The ten best pizza places in Thunder Bay

Best Pizza Place Recommendations

1. Both Hands Wood-Fired Pizzeria & Bakery TripAdvisor ranks #1 locally

“Both Hands, I will say, has good pizza in any standard. I think they take the cake all over town…”

Repeatedly nominated as the best by Reddit users, the only true wood-fired pizza place in town with an excellent reputation.

2. Tomlin Subdivision（Detroit deep‑dish）

“Overall Subdivision wins best for me.”

A unique, rich, deep-dish style that satisfies cheese lovers.

3. Stan’s Pizza

“Stan’s is my go‑to. Thundercape, baby.”

A long-standing local favorite that remains popular, often ordered by both workers and families.

4. Franki’s

“When Franki’s is good, it’s so fucking good.”

Though sometimes inconsistent, at its peak it rivals top-tier pizza.

5. Po's Variety (Northwood area, open late)

“Po’s variety is slept on big time. Amazing pizza available until 4 am, with delivery!”

Top late-night choice, classic "hangover pizza."

6. Angelo's Pizza (Current River area)

“Angelo’s on Hodder… crust is a perfect combo of crispy outside/soft & chewy inside”

Praised for being not too oily or greasy, with great value for money.

7. Lento’s Wood‑Fired Pizza

“Lento’s pizza… so delicious! In my opinion the best pizza in Thunder Bay.”

8. Gallucci’s Pizza

“Not only the best pizza in ThunderBay (IMHO), but stellar folks too!”

9. El Jefe（Dawson General Store）

“Their pepperoni pizza is hands down my favorite.”

10. Donato’s Bakery Pizza

“Donato’s bakery makes great pizza!”

The above rankings are based on ratings and reviews from online platforms such as TripAdvisor, Yelp, and Reddit, for reference only. Actual experiences may vary depending on personal taste and current circumstances.